• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Jeff Brooke Team

  • Home
  • Practice Areas
    • Car Accident Lawyers
    • Truck Accidents
    • Wrongful Death
    • Premises Liability
    • Products Liability Lawyers
    • Slip & Fall Lawyers
    • Dog Bite Injury
    • Workers Compensation
    • Brain Injury Lawyer
    • Distracted Driving Accident
    • Boating Accident
    • Motorcycle Accident
    • Pedestrian Accident
  • Our Team
  • Our Victories
    • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Contact Us

(757) 552-6055

  • Home
  • Practice Areas
    • Car Accident Lawyers
    • Truck Accidents
    • Wrongful Death
    • Premises Liability
    • Products Liability Lawyers
    • Slip & Fall Lawyers
    • Dog Bite Injury
    • Workers Compensation
    • Brain Injury Lawyer
    • Distracted Driving Accident
    • Boating Accident
    • Motorcycle Accident
    • Pedestrian Accident
  • Our Team
  • Our Victories
    • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
Call
Contact
Blog

Serious Injury Claim Up In Smoke?

28 May By: The Jeff Brooke Team | 3 Minutes read

State Bar Required Disclaimer: The results of specific cases reported are not meant to be a prediction or guarantee of any other case. Each case depends upon a variety of factors specific to that case.

While we have been representing injury victims for decades in this area, it is amazing how often new legal issues can come up. Just when you think you have seen it all. . .

We recently began our preparations for a slip and fall trial. Our client had sustained serious injuries when a large local retailer failed to remove snow and ice from its premises. To make matters worse, the retailer’s employees had been aware for 20 years that a roof drain had been emitting freezing water directly onto a pedestrian walkway. They would occasionally salt the area but in this case, three days after the snowstorm, they simply forgot to do so. While slip and fall cases can be difficult, we strongly believe that the retailer’s failures constitute negligence on their part. As if their negligence were not enough, the retailer takes the position that the injury victim’s failure to quit smoking is a defense in this case.

To be fair, our client had been advised to quit smoking before. He had developed an addiction to tobacco as a young man and had had extreme difficulty in quitting. It is also true that cigarette smoking has complicated his recovery. Following surgery for severe fractures, the surgical wounds just did not heal well. Our client sadly has had to go through a number of skin grafting procedures to make the wound sites close.

The legal question is whether the retailer may use our client’s tobacco addiction against him. Virginia law on damages addresses a number of points but not necessarily this one. In general, an injury victim cannot claim damages for injuries that they have aggravated through their own negligence. But there is also an important concept that “the defendant takes the plaintiff as it finds him,” i.e. the defendant is obligated to pay damages for all of the consequences that flow from its negligence. If a relatively minor impact causes a fragile plaintiff to require surgery, the defendant cannot complain about the plaintiff’s pre-existing fragile condition.

And, so it would seem with tobacco use. To our client’s credit, he was finally able to kick the habit during his recovery — something that will help him both medically and legally in the long run. Isn’t tobacco addiction a “pre-existing condition?” How fair (or legal) is it for the defendant to now claim that the skin grafting and other complications which may have flowed from tobacco smoking are not their responsibility? When they neglected their obligations with regard to the public, weren’t they taking the chance that anyone (a tobacco addict? an elderly person? a child? a person walking with a cane?) might slip and fall and sustain an unusually bad injury.

As we said, new and interesting questions come up all the time. The moral of the story is, of course, to quit smoking (especially if you find you’re in a lawsuit or with any type of injury or illness). We will see what the court rules and update you as the matter proceeds. If you have been in a slip and fall accident in Virginia Beach or the Hampton Roads area, contact The Jeff Brooke Team and we will be glad to assist you.

Posted By Jeff Brooke

Categorized: Personal Injury

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Primary Sidebar

Speak to Our Virginia Beach Law Firm Today

Practice Areas

  • Car Accident Attorney
  • Truck Accident
  • Wrongful Death
  • Premises Liability
  • Products Liability
  • Slip & Fall Lawyers
  • Dog Bite Lawyers
  • Workers Compensation
  • Brain Injury
  • Distracted Driving Accident
  • Boating Accident
  • Motorcycle Accident

What Our Clients Say

P. Smith

When I needed a personal injury attorney I turned to Jeff Brooke. I would recommend anyone who needs to be represented well to hire Mr. Brooke. Jeff's professional and personal demeanor was top notch. The skills and personal touches provided by both Jeff and his team were exceptional. Jeff is very warm, puts you at ease and gets the best results for his clients.

Tierra R.

Even though I did not have a huge case, I wanted to win. Jeff fought for me and got me a nice settlement. I was glad when we didn't even have to go to court.

Melvis C.

I was really glad to be referred to The Jeff Brooke Team. I felt it was divine intervention. I am a very, very satisfied client.

J. Neal

I am very happy and thankful for the services of Jeffrey Brooke. He and his crew helped me obtain a fair and timely settlement of my injury claim related to an auto accident in 2013. He acted thoughtfully and carefully to protect me and for my maximum benefit.

Ashley

Everyone was absolutely amazing to work with and so helpful with any questions or concerns I may have had during my case. I would truly recommend them to everyone no matter where you may be located, this is the team you want to fight for you and the things you deserve in personal injury cases. I absolutely loved working with each member of this awesome team.

V. Velasquez

I enjoyed working with The Jeff Brooke Team on my personal injury case. He kept me informed and really fought for me in the negotiation part of the settlement. I would recommend Jeff as a personal injury attorney to anyone.

View All TESTIMONIALS

Footer

Useful Links

  • Our Team
  • Our Victories
  • Virginia Beach Pedestrian Accident Lawyer
  • Contact Us

Contact Us

Virginia Beach

4705 Columbus Street, Suite 100
Virginia Beach, VA 23462-6749

(757) 552-6055
(757) 552-6016
Mail Us

Our Office

Practice Areas

  • Car Accident Attorney
  • Truck Accident
  • Wrongful Death
  • Premises Liability
  • Products Liability
  • Slip & Fall Lawyers
  • Dog Bite Lawyers
  • Workers Compensation
  • Brain Injury
  • Distracted Driving Accident
  • Boating Accident
  • Motorcycle Accident

Latest Blog

Recent Posts

  • 5 Reasons You Should NOT Handle Your Own Car Accident Claim in Virginia Beach
  • What to Do After a Dog Bite
  • If My Child Trespasses and Gets Injured, Can I Still Sue?
  • Is the Employer of an At-Fault Driver Legally Liable for Your Auto Accident Injuries?

View All Posts

© The Jeff Brooke Team - 2023. All rights reserved.